Recalls & Safety

Your Old Insignia Air Fryer Could Be Worth $75 — Here’s How I Claimed Mine (US & Canada Recall Guide, 2026)

Last updated: November 7, 2026

Bonjour! It’s J. — 💰 Got an Insignia air fryer from Best Buy sitting on your counter? It might be worth a $75 Best Buy gift card — even without a receipt. Best Buy recalled Insignia air fryers twice (2022 and 2024) over fire and burn hazards, and the refund program is still running in 2026. I know because mine was recalled, and I received my refund.

This is my personal experience plus everything you need to check yours.

🌿 Quick Take

  • Flip your air fryer over and find the model number on the bottom label — don’t judge by size or design.
  • Insignia air fryers were recalled twice — in 2022 and 2024 — over fire and burn hazards, so compare against both recall tables below.
  • If it matches: stop using it and follow the refund steps.
  • Canada, 2024 recall: a Best Buy gift card for the full purchase price with a receipt, $75 without one.
  • My own recalled unit (3.4 Qt Analog, NS-AF32MBK9-C) earned me the $75 — the program is still running in 2026.
  • Never sell or give away a recalled air fryer — it’s illegal in Canada and the US.

🙋 My Story: I Had No Idea Until I Saw the News

I own an Insignia 3.4 Qt Analog Air Fryer (Model NS-AF32MBK9-C) — the black one with the two dials on top. I bought it around late December 2020, and I’d been using it for years with zero problems.

Here’s the thing: my model was part of the 2022 Canadian recall, but I heard nothing about it for years. Then I happened to see a news article about the recall by chance. That’s how I found out.

I registered on the official recall site, and about a week later, I received a $75 Best Buy gift card. I actually had my receipt, but the sale price on it was about a dollar less than $75 — so I just skipped the receipt and took the flat $75. The process was surprisingly simple.

After using it for years, I put in a little extra money and upgraded to a better, newer model. I’ll be posting a review of the new one soon — stay tuned.

If you bought an Insignia air fryer from Best Buy, check your model number today. You might have an unclaimed refund like I did.

🚨 Two Recalls, Not One — Here’s Why That Matters

Insignia air fryers were recalled twice:

2022 Recall 2024 Recall
Announced April 21, 2022 March 14, 2024
Issue Overheating → fire & burn risk Overheating → handles melting/breaking, glass door shattering
Canada units ~138,570 ~99,903
US units ~634,522 ~187,400
Sold Nov 2018 – Apr 2022 Sep 2021 – Nov 2023

The two recalls cover different models, so you need to check both lists.

📋 2022 Recall — Affected Models

🇨🇦 Canada (Health Canada RA-64096) — 6 Models

Product Model Number
Insignia 10 Qt Digital Air Fryer Oven – Black NS-AFO6DSS1-C
Insignia 3.4 Qt Analog Air Fryer – Black NS-AF32MBK9-C ⭐ Mine
Insignia 5.3 Qt Digital Air Fryer Oven – Stainless Steel NS-AF50DBK0-C
Insignia 10 Qt Analog Air Fryer – Black NS-AF50MBK9-C
Insignia 5 Qt Analog Air Fryer – Stainless Steel NS-AF53MSS0-C
Insignia Digital Air Fryer – Family Size – Black NS-AF55DBK9-C

🇺🇸 United States (CPSC Recall #22-125) — 8 Models

  • NS-AF32DBK9
  • NS-AF32MBK9
  • NS-AF50MBK9
  • NS-AF53DSS0
  • NS-AF53MSS0
  • NS-AF55DBK9
  • NS-AFO6DBK1
  • NS-AFO6DSS1

My own recalled unit — the 3.4 Qt analog model (NS-AF32MBK9-C), the one marked ⭐ in the table above. Photo by me.

📋 2024 Recall — Affected Models

Also recalled in Canada (Health Canada RA-75178) — 5 models:

Product Model Number SKU
Insignia 5QT Analog Air Fryer – Stainless Steel NS-AF5MSS2-C 15596242
Insignia 5L / 5.28Qt Digital Air Fryer – Black NS-AF50DBK2-C 15605777
Insignia 8 QT Digital Dual Basket Air Fryer – Black NS-AF8DBD2-C 15545537
Insignia 10 QT Digital Air Fryer Oven – Stainless Steel NS-AF10DSS2-C 15596240
Insignia 3.4 QT Analog Air Fryer – Black NS-AF32MBK2-C 15605776

Also recalled in the US (CPSC #24-159) — 6 models:

  • NS-AF34D2
  • NS-AF5DSS2
  • NS-AF5MSS2
  • NS-AF8DBD2
  • NS-AF10DBK2
  • NS-AF10DSS2

⭐ US and Canadian model lists are NOT identical. Always check the list for the country where you bought it.

🔍 How to Check If YOUR Air Fryer Is Recalled (30 Seconds)

The rating label on the bottom of my own Insignia air fryer — model number NS-AF32MBK9-C
Flip it over: the model number is on the rating label underneath. This is my own unit — NS-AF32MBK9-C, on the 2022 recall list. Photo by me.

Don’t judge by size or design. Check the model number.

  1. Unplug your air fryer and let it cool completely.
  2. Flip it over and find the rating label on the bottom (underside).
  3. Look for INSIGNIA and the Model Number (e.g. NS-AF32MBK9-C).
  4. Compare it against the lists above — include the “-C” suffix for Canadian models.

💰 How Much Can You Get? (My Experience + Official Terms)

Canada — 2024 recall details:

  • ✅ With receipt: Best Buy gift card for the full purchase price
  • ✅ Without receipt: $75 Best Buy gift card (officially stated)

Canada — 2022 recall (my case):

  • Health Canada states a credit for use at Best Buy Canada
  • My experience: I applied without a receipt and received a $75 Best Buy gift card about a week later

US — 2022 recall:

  • CPSC notice: $50 credit without receipt; receipt amount if higher than $50

⭐ Don’t mix up the US and Canadian terms. Check the official notice for your country.

📝 How to File Your Claim — Step by Step

2022 Recall

  • 🌐 Online: www.recallrtr.com/airfryer (the old 2022 portal now redirects here)
  • ☎️ Phone: 1-877-650-5411 (Mon–Fri, 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM ET, except holidays)

2024 Recall

What You’ll Need

  1. 📸 Photo of the model number (rating label on the bottom)
  2. 📸 Photo of the unit with the power cord cut (follow the official site’s instructions — don’t just throw it away)
  3. 🧾 Purchase receipt (if you have one — not required)

🛑 Do NOT Just Bring It to the Store

This is not a regular return. Health Canada explicitly says do not return recalled air fryers to a Best Buy retail store. Register through the official recall process instead.

🔬 Why Air Fryers Get Fire-Hazard Recalls (The Engineering Side)

Ever wonder why a cooking appliance that worked fine for years suddenly gets recalled for fire risk? Here is the general engineering picture — it made the whole thing click for me.

An air fryer is basically a very intense heater: a high-wattage heating element plus a fan, packed into a small plastic-and-metal shell. In normal use, that is fine — thermostats and thermal fuses are the safety backstops that cut power if things get too hot. Fire-hazard recalls in cooking appliances generally come down to something in that safety chain: a component that can overheat, a connection that degrades over time, or a design where heat can reach materials it should not.

Here is what that means in practice:

  • Recalls are about risk, not your unit’s history. Yours may have run flawlessly for years — mine did. The recall means a failure pattern was found across the product line, and your unit carries the same pattern. That is why regulators say stop using it regardless.
  • Crumb buildup makes things worse. In any heating appliance, food debris near a heating element is fuel waiting for a spark. Regular cleaning is good practice for every air fryer, recalled or not.
  • High wattage means high stakes. A 1500W+ appliance pulls a lot of current through a small plug and internal wiring. That is why safety certifications (like UL or ETL marks) matter when you buy a replacement — they mean an independent lab tested the design against recognized safety standards.

The $75 refund is not compensation for a broken product. It is the remedy for a product line that carries a documented safety risk — and taking it is the smart move.

⚠️ Stop Using It — Even If It Works Fine

Mine worked perfectly for years. That doesn’t matter. A recall isn’t about whether your unit has malfunctioned — it’s about a confirmed safety defect in the model line. If your model is on the list, unplug it and file the claim.

🚫 Can You Sell a Recalled Air Fryer?

No. Under Canada’s Canada Consumer Product Safety Act, it’s illegal to resell, redistribute, or even give away a recalled product in Canada. Same principle applies in the US under CPSC rules. Don’t list it on Marketplace. Don’t give it to a friend. File the claim.

🎯 The Bottom Line

I almost missed out on $75 because I didn’t know my air fryer was recalled. A news article I happened to see saved me.

🔗 Official Recall Links

This post is part of the Pennies from Heaven series — real money hiding in your home, and how to claim it. Recall terms may change; always verify on the official sites before filing.

Wishing you a beautiful day.

Get the Free Canada Savings Checklist

Join the newsletter — get the free PDF checklist and weekly Canada savings tips in your inbox.

Some links in this post are referral or affiliate links. If you sign up or buy through them, I may receive a bonus or commission at no extra cost to you. It helps keep this blog running — thank you!

J.

Julie (J.) — Montréal-based writer, nine years in Canada. Every review here is of something I bought with my own money and used to the end; every guide starts from my own trips, receipts and membership emails.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *