Eastern Canada

Buffalo, New York: A Landmark Hotel, a 1926 Wonder Theatre and the Original Buffalo Wing

Last updated: November 5, 2026

Bonjour! It’s J. — and today I want to show you the Buffalo I actually met: not a drive-through on the way somewhere else, but a city where we slept inside a National Historic Landmark, walked a theatre district from bright afternoon to neon night, and ate the original Buffalo wing at the bar that invented it.

Buffalo sits just across the border country we cross on our Québec road trips, and it rewards anyone who stops instead of passing through. On this trip we based ourselves at The Richardson Hotel, set inside the Richardson Olmsted Campus, then spent our evenings downtown, where Main Street strings together a 1926 wonder theatre, a red-lit Art Deco city hall and some of the best people-watching in New York State.

Every photo in this post is mine, and I am showing you the whole walk — the hotel by night, its gallery-like corridors, the theatre district by day, downtown after dark, and the two food stops I would cross the border for again. Let’s start where we slept.

🌿 Quick Take

  • The Richardson Hotel sits inside a National Historic Landmark designed by H.H. Richardson, with grounds by Frederick Law Olmsted
  • The hotel’s corridors double as a gallery — go at night, when the globe lights are on
  • Shea’s Buffalo Theatre opened in 1926 as “The Wonder Theatre” and still anchors Main Street
  • Downtown after dark is the show: a red-lit City Hall, a gold-domed bank and the Electric Tower
  • Anchor Bar, at 1047 Main Street, is the official “Home of the Original Buffalo Wing” — and yes, we went twice

🏨 Sleeping inside a National Historic Landmark

The Richardson Hotel is not a hotel with a historic theme. It is a hotel inside the history itself. The campus was designed in the late 1800s by architect H.H. Richardson, with landscape design by Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux — the same Olmsted who designed New York’s Central Park and Buffalo’s own park system.

It was originally built as a groundbreaking centre for mental health treatment, planned around the Kirkbride idea that sunlight, air and beautiful surroundings were part of the cure. The buildings were later emptied and left to decay, until restoration began in the early 2000s. Today the Towers Building and its adjoining wings welcome guests as The Richardson Hotel, at 444 Forest Avenue. View on Google Maps

Arriving after dark is pure theatre. The twin towers glow green against the sky, the stone façade warms up under the lamps, and the arched entrance pours light onto the plaza. I stood on the lawn far longer than check-in required, just looking up.

The Richardson Hotel's stone façade and green-lit twin towers at night, the arched entrance glowing
The Richardson Hotel front at night — those twin towers glow green over the whole campus
A wide night view of the Richardson Olmsted Campus, towers and lamp-lit grounds
The campus grounds at night, with the hotel wings stretching out on both sides
The side of The Richardson Hotel at night, one tower rising above the stone wing
The tower wing from the side — Richardsonian Romanesque stone, floor after floor of tall windows
The Richardson Hotel seen from the parking area under a bright moon, its modern glass entrance canopy lit
Even the walk back from the car is a view here — moon over the towers

The campus is a National Historic Landmark, and the Richardson Olmsted Campus site describes it as a 42-acre site in the heart of Buffalo’s cultural corridor, being brought back building by building. The hotel’s own history page tells the full story, from Kirkbride to today.

We stay in a lot of beautiful hotels on the Charlevoix coast — the Fairmont Le Manoir Richelieu is our cold-season refuge — but The Richardson is a different category of stay. At the Fairmont, the view is the river. Here, the building itself is the sight, and you sleep inside it.

🖼️ Corridors that behave like a gallery

Most hotels treat hallways as plumbing — a way to move guests from lift to door. The Richardson’s corridors are destinations. Ring after ring of globe chandeliers marches down the long gallery, with oversized photo prints of Buffalo’s architecture on both walls.

The grand staircase makes the same point in wood: a broad, polished flight rising past carved cornices to a mezzanine, with a ring of globe lights hanging over the lobby floor. Signs point you to the hotel’s restaurant, Cucina, and to Bar Vaux — everything you need is inside the landmark.

The Richardson Hotel lobby with its grand wooden staircase, mezzanine and a ring of globe lights
The grand staircase lobby — wood, carved cornices and that ring of globe lights
A curved lobby gallery at The Richardson Hotel with mosaic tile floors, tall arched windows and the Olmsted Wing door
The curved lobby gallery, with its patterned tile floor and Buffalo photo prints
The hanging Olmsted Wing sign at The Richardson Hotel, above a small sofa lounge
The Olmsted Wing entrance — even the room wings get a proper sign
A long corridor at The Richardson Hotel lined with photo prints and repeating globe chandeliers
The corridor gallery — chandeliers repeating all the way down
A lounge corner in a Richardson Hotel corridor, with tall grid windows, a chess table and a large photo print of the towers
A corridor lounge corner, with a chess table under the big windows
Two large photo prints of Buffalo's historic stone architecture hanging on a corridor wall at The Richardson Hotel
Buffalo’s stone architecture, framed on the corridor wall

My favourite detail is the corner lounge at the end of one corridor: tall grid windows, a small table with a chess set, and a huge print of the towers themselves on the wall. The hotel keeps introducing you to its own past, one room at a time.

💡 Tip: Walk the corridors after dinner, when the day visitors are gone and the globe lights reflect in the tall windows — the whole floor turns quiet and golden.

🎭 Main Street by day: the theatre district

Downtown, Main Street runs on rails — the Metro Rail tracks split the roadway, and the theatres line up along it. In daylight the district is all painted signs and old brick: the Wurlitzer Flats wall sign, the Shea’s Smith Theatre blade sign, and a banner celebrating Buffalo, “City of Light.” View on Google Maps

Main Street in Buffalo by day, with Metro Rail tracks, the Wurlitzer Flats wall sign and the Shea's Smith Theatre sign
Main Street by day — the Wurlitzer Flats sign, Shea’s Smith Theatre and the Metro Rail tracks

And then the block gives you its postcard. Shea’s Buffalo Theatre opened in 1926 under the moniker “The Wonder Theatre”, as the dream of Buffalo theatre magnate Michael Shea. It began as a Paramount movie house boasting “an acre of seats,” later hosted vaudeville and names like the Marx Brothers and Frank Sinatra, and today it is the touring Broadway house of the Shea’s Performing Arts Center. View on Google Maps

Shea's Buffalo Theatre by day, its tall vertical sign and ornate façade on Main Street
Shea’s Buffalo by day — the vertical sign and “The Wonder Theatre” over the doors

Next door, Shea’s Smith Theatre is the intimate sibling: a 237-seat black box theatre that has hosted Off-Broadway productions, comedy and local companies since 2000. One street, two completely different scales of stage — that contrast is the district in a nutshell.

🌃 Downtown Buffalo after dark

Come back at night. Seriously — whatever your plans are, move them. After dark, Shea’s vertical sign lights up letter by letter, the marquee glows over the empty rail tracks, and the whole district turns into the set of a film nobody is shooting.

Shea's Buffalo Theatre at night, its vertical sign and marquee fully lit above the Metro Rail crossing
Shea’s Buffalo at night — this is the shot the whole street is arranged for
Shea's Buffalo Theatre at night from an angle, marquee and façade lights reflecting on Main Street
The same corner from an angle — marquee, façade and quiet tracks
Shea's Smith Theatre's lit sign at night, with Shea's Buffalo's vertical sign glowing further down Main Street
Shea’s Smith in front, Shea’s Buffalo glowing down the street
The illuminated Buffalo Theatre District sign and the Plaza of Stars at night
The Theatre District sign at the Plaza of Stars

Walk a few blocks and the landmarks stack up. The Liberty Building carries its Statue of Liberty replica on the roofline. At Niagara Square, Buffalo City Hall — an Art Deco masterpiece dedicated in 1932, according to Visit Buffalo Niagara — was lit a deep red the night we passed, with the McKinley Monument in front of it. View on Google Maps

The Liberty Building in downtown Buffalo at night, its Statue of Liberty replica on top, at Franklin Street
The Liberty Building, with its Statue of Liberty replica riding the roofline
Buffalo City Hall lit red at night, seen from Franklin Street near Niagara Square
City Hall washed red for the night, over Niagara Square
Buffalo City Hall's Art Deco tower lit red at night, framed by two stone buildings on Niagara Square
Buffalo City Hall lit up in red at night, seen from Franklin Street.
The gold dome of the Buffalo Savings Bank building and the Electric Tower lit in red and blue on Main Street at night
A gold dome and the Electric Tower sharing one frame on Main Street

The last frame of the walk is my favourite: the gold dome of the old Buffalo Savings Bank building glowing beside the Electric Tower, lit in red and blue. The Electric Tower’s own site notes it was built in 1912, modelled on the temporary tower of the 1901 Pan-American Exposition — Buffalo has been lighting this skyline for a very long time.

💡 Tip: City Hall’s observation deck is the daytime counterpart — Visit Buffalo Niagara describes an elevator to the 25th floor, then three flights up for the “Windows on Buffalo” view.

🍗 Two food stops I would cross the border for

A Buffalo trip runs on two food groups: barbecue and wings. For barbecue, we sat down at Dinosaur Bar-B-Que’s downtown room — a glass-block bar, stained-glass chandeliers, and a small herd of painted metal pigs and roosters standing guard over the bottles. It is loud, warm and exactly as unpretentious as barbecue should be.

Inside Dinosaur Bar-B-Que in Buffalo — a glass-block bar with colourful metal animal sculptures and stained-glass chandeliers
The Dinosaur Bar-B-Que bar — glass blocks, stained glass and metal pigs
The full menu board at Dinosaur Bar-B-Que in Buffalo - starters, pit plates, combo plates, sandwiches and homemade sides
The full menu board — ribs, combo plates and homemade sides
The Today's Specials chalkboard inside Dinosaur Bar-B-Que in Buffalo, with canned cocktails and desserts
The day’s specials board — canned cocktails and key lime pie

One honest note before you plan around it: the downtown room in our photos closed in early 2025, and Dinosaur Bar-B-Que has moved to Hamburg (4245 McKinley Parkway). The downtown room fed us very well — this meal is now a memory, and a delicious one. View on Google Maps

Then there is the pilgrimage. Anchor Bar, at 1047 Main Street, is the “Home of the Original Buffalo Wing” — that is the restaurant’s own official title, and its story is Buffalo’s proudest food legend: in 1964, Teressa Bellissimo created the first Buffalo wing here, deep-frying wings and tossing them in a secret sauce. View on Google Maps

And here is my confession: the wings were so good that we went to Anchor Bar twice during this one Buffalo trip — and on the way home to Montréal, we carried a box of them with us. Some restaurants you review. This one, we simply went back to, and then took it home in a box.

A red Anchor Bar takeout box — Frank & Teressa's Anchor Bar, Home of the Original Buffalo Wing
The famous red box — proof that the wings came home to Montréal with us

I have a soft spot for places that earn a second visit inside a single trip. It is the same instinct that keeps sending me back to a certain Montréal taqueria — I wrote about that habit in my 3 Amigos post. Anchor Bar earned it in one weekend.

🗺️ How I would plan this Buffalo stop

Buffalo works beautifully as the overnight stop on a longer road trip. Sleep at The Richardson for the architecture, give the theatre district one full evening — day walk first, then the same streets after dark — and put Anchor Bar on the schedule twice, because you will want to anyway.

It also chains naturally with the drives I write about here. Coming down from Québec, the same slow-travel rhythm runs through our Pointe-au-Pic village walk and the free Tadoussac ferry crossing: small places, taken slowly, photographed properly. Buffalo is bigger, but it rewards exactly the same pace.

Quick question before you go: have you ever eaten a food in its actual birthplace — the original wing, in the original bar? Tell me below — I read every answer.

Buffalo cityscape from above at dusk
La Belle Vie de J.
Niagara Falls from above at dusk
La Belle Vie de J.
Shea's theatre street in Buffalo at night
La Belle Vie de J.
Shea's theatre marquee in Buffalo at night, close-up
La Belle Vie de J.
Aerial view of Niagara Falls at dusk
La Belle Vie de J.

Happy wandering 💛
— J.

❓ FAQ

Where is The Richardson Hotel, and what is the Richardson Olmsted Campus?

The Richardson Hotel is at 444 Forest Avenue, Buffalo, inside the Richardson Olmsted Campus — a 42-acre National Historic Landmark designed in the late 1800s by H.H. Richardson, with grounds by Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux. The campus was originally built as a centre for mental health treatment, and the Towers Building now houses the hotel.

Can you visit the Richardson Olmsted Campus without staying overnight?

Yes — the campus presents itself as a place to visit as well as to stay, and its official site offers scheduled tours of the grounds and towers. The hotel corridors and lobby areas are worth the stop on their own; check the campus site for current tour times before you go.

What is Shea’s Buffalo Theatre?

Shea’s Buffalo Theatre, at 646 Main Street, opened in 1926 under the moniker “The Wonder Theatre.” Built by Michael Shea as a Paramount movie house with “an acre of seats,” it is now the historic crown jewel of Shea’s Performing Arts Center and Buffalo’s touring Broadway house. Its smaller sibling, Shea’s Smith Theatre at 658 Main Street, is a 237-seat black box theatre.

Where was the Buffalo wing invented?

At Anchor Bar, 1047 Main Street in Buffalo — officially the “Home of the Original Buffalo Wing.” By the restaurant’s own account, Teressa Bellissimo created the first Buffalo wing there in 1964, deep-frying chicken wings and tossing them in a secret sauce.

Is Dinosaur Bar-B-Que still in downtown Buffalo?

No — the downtown Franklin Street room in our photos closed in early 2025. Dinosaur Bar-B-Que now serves the Buffalo area from Hamburg, New York (4245 McKinley Parkway), so check the official site for current hours and head there instead.

📚 You May Also Like

Get the Free Canada Savings Checklist

Join the newsletter — get the free PDF checklist and weekly Canada savings tips in your inbox.

Some links in this post are referral or affiliate links. If you sign up or buy through them, I may receive a bonus or commission at no extra cost to you. It helps keep this blog running — thank you!

J.

Julie (J.) — Montréal-based writer, nine years in Canada. Every review here is of something I bought with my own money and used to the end; every guide starts from my own trips, receipts and membership emails.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *